Dasean Lewis, 24, Christopher Leake, 19, and Nahji Mayes, 23, targeted vehicles left unlocked with key fobs inside, Marlboro police said.
Marlboro Police Department was assisted by the U.S. Marshals Task Force in the arrest of Lewis and Mayes. Leake was jailed on other charges when he was arrested, police said.
All three were being held in Monmouth County Correctional Facility in Freehold.
Det. Sgt. Jon Gramcko, Det. Edward Ungrady and Det. Michael Pecoraro led the investigation.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Lakewood and receive free news updates.